Review of Homerun Proposal (Orleans University, #1) by [Author’s Name]
From the second I stumbled across Homerun Proposal, I knew I was either about to dive headfirst into a whirlwind sports romance or brace myself for a wild ride of emotional turmoil. With an intriguing premise featuring a best friend’s brother dynamic and the added spice of a virgin FMC and manhoe MMC, I was ready to see how this charming yet complicated love story would unfold.
The book revolves around Lane and Hallie, two college students navigating the murky waters of desire, friendship, and past entanglements. Lane, a notorious playboy who seems to have a revolving door of flings, and Hallie, Eli’s (Lane’s younger brother) best friend and a sweet, quirky podcast enthusiast, find themselves in a hilariously mismatched yet compelling situation. Initially, I struggled to warm up to Lane. It was hard to reconcile his “secret pining” for Hallie with his brazen attitude toward his dating life. If he’s been after her since high school, why the casual hookups? It felt contradictory to the heartfelt narrative the author was trying to weave.
One of my biggest points of frustration was that despite Lane’s moments of sweetness—like when he tenderly cared for Hallie’s painful cramps—his earlier reckless behavior left a sour taste in my mouth. How can a character be both endearing yet infuriating? The author’s writing style is conversational, making it easy to slide into the story, yet the pacing occasionally stuttered, mirroring Hallie’s own stammering interactions with Lane. This aspect, while intended to be cute, became tedious and ultimately detracted from my enjoyment of Hallie’s character. I longed for more growth from her, especially by the end, but found her quirks more exasperating than charming.
There were certainly moments where the emotional tension simmered just below the surface. Still, I found myself scratching my head at Lane’s grand gestures, which, while meant to be romantic, bordered on being cringe-worthy. Wouldn’t it have been more sincere to express his feelings in a more private setting rather than on a public stage? The grand confession felt akin to a movie scene, scripted yet lacking the real emotional punch I craved.
Despite my frustrations, I can appreciate the themes of discovery, vulnerability, and the exploration of sexuality that permeate the narrative. Hallie’s journey to embrace her desires is commendable, and the dynamic between her and Lane captures the complexity of young adult relationships. For readers who enjoy steamy scenes and enjoyable banter rooted in college life, Homerun Proposal offers that in spades.
In conclusion, while Homerun Proposal didn’t entirely resonate with me, it might just be the lighthearted, escapist romance that other readers are searching for. If you’re a fan of sports romances that explore themes of friendship, desire, and self-acceptance, you might find a gem here. Personally, I left the experience a bit dissatisfied, but I’m hopeful that Lane and Hallie’s journey will appeal to others who crave that spicy blend of tension and tumult. After all, every reader’s taste differs, and what might not be for me could be someone’s next favorite book!
Discover more about Homerun Proposal (Orleans University, #1) on GoodReads >>