Review of Good Girl, Bad Blood by Holly Jackson
If you’re like me, you might have been utterly captivated by Holly Jackson’s A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder. The blend of mystery, complex characters, and gritty realism left a lasting impression. Naturally, when I discovered that the sequel, Good Girl, Bad Blood, was on the horizon, I couldn’t wait to dive back into Pip’s world. But while I was eager for more of her detective antics, I had to brace myself; the path Pip navigates this time is fraught with personal stakes and emotional depth that surprised me.
In this second installment, we find Pip, our ever-determined protagonist, stepping away from her detective role due to the chaotic aftermath of her first investigation and the incredible pressure from her family. With her podcast going viral, it seems like she’s finally turning a new leaf. Yet, just when she thinks she can escape the shadows of her investigative past, Jamie Reynolds mysteriously disappears on the night of a memorial that echoes the tragic events of the first book. Contrasting her initial instinct to let the police handle it, Pip finds herself pulled back into the fray, reigniting her podcast and investigative spirit.
What struck me most was how Jackson handles mature themes, especially relating to emotional abuse and the labels we place on ourselves and others. Pip’s journey is as much about uncovering secrets as it is about grappling with her identity, a theme that resonates deeply. Phrases like "You’re a waste of space," echo impactfully throughout the narrative, scriptive of toxic dynamics that many readers might recognize. This deeply personal exploration juxtaposes the pulse-pounding mystery with an emotional undercurrent that makes the story richer.
The pacing of the story deserves mention. While it begins rather slowly, the narrative quickly accelerates into a gripping ride that reminded me of classic mystery tales—think Enid Blyton or the Hardy Boys, but with a darker twist. I was especially struck by Jackson’s ability to balance tension with thoughtful reflection. However, the resolution felt somewhat lacking for me; the latter half of the book introduces new plot threads that, while intriguing, lacked adequate foreshadowing and felt disjointed from the core narrative.
One of my favorite lines encapsulates this beautifully: "Everything’s a clue until we discount it." It speaks not only to the detective work Pip undertakes but also to how we should approach understanding people and their motivations. I found myself nodding as I read these lines, reflecting on how often we dismiss the signs around us—whether in relationships or in society.
Despite some pacing issues in the latter half, I can confidently recommend Good Girl, Bad Blood to anyone who enjoyed the first book. It’s a compelling tale of resilience that dives into complex familial relationships and the quiet predators hiding in plain sight. Young readers, especially those who appreciate a well-crafted mystery, will find much to enjoy within these pages.
Ultimately, reading this book offered me not just a thrill but a wealth of insights regarding empathy, understanding, and personal growth. As Pip closes another chapter in her life, I, too, found myself reflecting on my own relationships and the words we sometimes wish we could take back.
So, if you’re in the mood for a cleverly woven mystery that doesn’t shy away from the darker aspects of human relationships, grab a copy of Good Girl, Bad Blood. It’s a journey worth taking—imperfections and all.
Feel free to join me on this reading adventure by connecting on Instagram, Twitter, or any of my social media platforms! Happy reading!
Discover more about Good Girl, Bad Blood (A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder, #2… on GoodReads >>