Book Review: Now She’s Dead by Roselyn Clarke
When I first picked up Now She’s Dead, I was immediately intrigued by Roselyn Clarke’s exploration of teenage guilt and the complexities of friendship. The novel’s premise—a psychological thriller about a tragic friendship set against the backdrop of a seemingly idyllic resort—promised both suspense and depth, two elements I deeply cherish in young adult fiction. I wasn’t disappointed.
The story revolves around eighteen-year-old Mandy Jenkins, who returns to the Highmark Inn & Resort, a place where her life—and her best friend, Sara Ellis’s—took a dark turn a year prior. As layers of mystery unfold, Mandy is forced to confront not only the circumstances of Sara’s tragic death but also her own guilt and trauma. Clarke’s portrayal of Mandy is refreshingly authentic. She is a flawed protagonist grappling with panic attacks and academic decline, a stark reminder of how trauma can chain us down.
Clarke excels at developing relationships in this novel. The sibling dynamic between Mandy and her younger sister, Kelsey, is particularly moving; Kelsey’s traumatic interpretation of events adds complexity to their interactions, grounding their relationship in real emotional stakes. The complexity of Sara, though her presence is anchored in flashbacks, is equally compelling. She’s neither a simple villain nor a misunderstood martyr; instead, she is a deeply troubled teenager with toxic patterns, making her a captivating but tragic figure.
The dual timeline structure Clarke employs is a clever narrative device that builds tension superbly. I found myself eagerly flipping pages, piecing together the puzzle of Sara’s death with each shift between "Now" and "Then." This approach allows for a richer development of both character and plot, preventing the story from feeling rushed—a trap many debut novels fall into. The resort setting itself becomes a character, its facade of wholesome fun juxtaposed with the darker themes of class tension and hidden desires.
What struck me most were Clarke’s nuanced themes, particularly the examination of unhealthy friendships. The Sara-Mandy dynamic serves as a poignant reminder of how love and dependency can, at times, morph into toxicity. Clarke doesn’t shy away from the messiness of this reality; both girls contribute to their downfall, leaving readers with much to ponder. Lines like, “Sometimes, the weight of guilt feels heavier than the truth,” resonated deeply with me, underscoring the book’s emotional depth.
One minor critique I have is that some side characters, particularly Natalie, felt a bit underdeveloped at times. I found myself wishing for a bit more flesh on the bones of her character as she navigated the intricate web of relationships at the resort. Additionally, while the resolution was filled with revelations, it felt slightly compressed compared to the slow burn of the preceding chapters.
That said, Now She’s Dead is a significant debut that not only thrills but also challenges readers to reflect on authenticity in friendships and the complexities of guilt. It’s perfect for those who enjoy character-driven mysteries with a blend of emotional weight and suspense. This book isn’t just about uncovering who’s responsible for Sara’s death; it’s about understanding the tangled web of human emotions tied to that loss.
In wrapping up my thoughts, I wholeheartedly recommend Roselyn Clarke’s debut to anyone who appreciates young adult literature that dives into the intricacies of human relationships—something I believe we can all relate to. Clarke’s voice is one I’ll be following closely; I can’t wait to see where her journey as an author takes her next.
Discover more about Now She’s Dead on GoodReads >>